Yes, more often than you might think.
At consultations, I quite often send people home without recommending surgery. In over 20 years focused on nasal surgery, I have increasingly made that judgment.
I once discussed surgery whenever improvement seemed possible. Now I weigh its benefits against what must be endured; if the latter weighs even slightly more, I advise against it.
There are several typical situations in which I do not recommend surgery.
First, when the nose in photos differs from the mirror. Lens distortion in selfies makes the nose look larger and more crooked than it is.
Many arrive convinced from photos that their nose is crooked, yet direct examination finds it within a normal range.
The same applies to the alae. Many requesting alar reduction have a low tip making the alae look spread, rather than truly broad alae.
Raising the tip alone naturally gathers the alae in these cases, so there is no reason to incise them.
Even if a patient requests a procedure, I believe a doctor’s job is to say when it is unnecessary.
Second, when improvement is smaller than the recovery burden, such as a very minor hump or a tip only 1–2 mm too low.
Surgery works in millimeters, but those millimeters require incisions, swelling and scar healing. I do not operate if the result cannot justify that process.
Third, when surrounding areas rather than the nose are the issue. A long philtrum or recessed chin can make the nose look larger and more drooped than it is.
Operating on the nose then can make facial balance awkward. Some are surprised when I direct attention elsewhere; looking only at the nose and operating is easy.
The difficult part—and my job—is judging the nose’s role in the whole face.
Finally, when the current nose is already good enough. Some want to reshape their nose to match a fashionable standard.
But fashions change and the operated nose remains. I do not support changing a nose that already suits the face just for a trend.
When surgery is needed, I say so clearly.
But I believe that judgment must weigh the patient’s wishes against the outcomes I have observed over more than 20 years.
I consider a consultation that ends with ‘You do not need surgery’ a good consultation too.
— Dr. Kim Hyung-taek, Director of KOWON Plastic Surgery
