The recommendation alone cannot tell you. Rib cartilage is appropriate even for some first operations, and unnecessary for others.
What matters is whether you received an explanation of why rib cartilage is needed.
Many think rib cartilage is only for revision patients, but it is not.
Rib cartilage offers the greatest quantity and strongest support among cartilage obtainable from the body.
So even at the first operation, it suits a very short nose needing substantial extension, congenitally weak or small septal cartilage for tip support,
or thick skin that prevents ordinary support from maintaining tip shape. Rib cartilage is appropriate from the start in these cases.
With only ear or septal cartilage, these noses may look fine initially but the tip can sink over time, eventually requiring rib cartilage at revision. It would have been better to use it from the start.
Conversely, a slight bridge lift and tip refinement give no reason to go as far as rib cartilage.
Using rib cartilage where septal or ear cartilage is enough creates an unnecessary additional chest incision.
In over 20 years of nasal surgery I have performed many rib-cartilage operations, but just as often told people their nose did not need it.
The nose’s condition determines the material, not the clinic.
If rib cartilage is recommended, rather than searching online about whether it is excessive, ask the recommending doctor this:
‘What condition in my nose makes rib cartilage necessary?’ A specific answer based on your nose makes the recommendation credible.
If the answer is merely that rib cartilage is the best material, seek another clinic’s opinion.
One further point: technique in handling rib cartilage affects results more than the material itself.
Shaping and assembling harvested cartilage appropriately can reduce warping. If you choose rib-cartilage surgery, also check that the surgeon has sufficient experience with it.
— Dr. Kim Hyung-taek, Director of KOWON Plastic Surgery
